New Manager? – Big Risks Ahead! Eight Signs to Watch Out For

Published on April 19th, 2017 by Alan L. Sklover

“The paranoid person is never entirely mistaken.”

– Sigmund Freud

ACTUAL CASE HISTORIES: Quite frankly, there are so many actual case histories of “New Manager Risk” that I could write an entire book on the subject. A large part of my law practice over these past 35 years has been devoted to severance, and I have identified five or six situations where we can almost expect our client to lose his or her job. Putting aside for the moment the “large-scale downsizing” category, the “New Manager” category is one of the most common “one-off,” or individual, job loss situations.

I often describe “New Manager Risk” this way: (1) new captain takes over the ship, (2) new captain is eager to show how much improvement she can bring about, (3) he thinks his best path to improvement is the hiring of a “new crew,” (4) she thinks that people she has known from other teams she has worked with will be very loyal, as well, and (5) one by one, the “old crew” are convinced, coaxed or coerced to “walk the plank.”

Sound familiar? I’d be surprised if it didn’t.

While I am confident everyone has seen or experienced this very scenario, I am absolutely certain that everyone will, sooner or later, come across it, themselves. Hopefully, when it happens, it will not happen to you.

LESSON TO LEARN: The lesson to learn here is quite simple: if you are assigned to a new manager, or a new manager is assigned to you, you need to be at least a touch extra vigilant, and consider taking extra steps to do all you can to keep your job. So, the first step is enhanced vigilance, the subject of this newsletter.

***Note that in coming weeks, we will write another newsletter about steps you can take to counteract “New Manager Risk” in order to keep your job. It will be entitled “New Manager? – Addressing the New Risks.” In the meantime, consider what events and circumstances you should look out for, as explained below.

WHAT YOU CAN DO: Here are eight things you can be on the lookout for if either you are assigned to a new manager, or a new manager is assigned to you:
Read the rest of this blog post »

“Will submitting a Performance Review rebuttal backfire?”

Published on November 6th, 2014 by Alan L. Sklover

Question: Dear Alan: I am considering writing a rebuttal to Human Resources to a vague, unfair comment made in my last performance review. I feel it was used to keep me from getting a raise.

When I asked my manager to explain the comment he could not do so, or even supply details. But, at the same time, he also said he would not change the comment.

What are the possible and most likely outcomes to writing a rebuttal? Will it damage my relationship with my manager? Will l look bad to future employers. Thanks in advance!

Detroit, Michigan

Answer: Dear Concerned: To one degree or another, your question is undoubtedly on the minds of every employee who considers standing up for himself or herself at work. It is a threshold issue, and it needs to be addressed, one way or the other. Read the rest of this blog post »

Performance Review a Problem? 16 Steps to a Robust Rebuttal

Published on July 24th, 2012 by Alan L Sklover

“The only perfect person
is a perfect idiot.”

-       Sklover Household Saying

ACTUAL “CASE HISTORIES”: For nine years, Margaret, was universally considered a top performer in her position as Vice President of Vacation Residences for a diversified real estate company. Time and again, internal audits showed her division to be among the most efficient, profitable and growing in the company. Year in and year out, Margaret’s performance reviews were either “exceeds expectations” or “meets all expectations.” What’s more, Margaret had received significant bonuses, promotions and awards for her good work. That is why Margaret didn’t see it coming.

In February of each year, Margaret’s company disseminated annual performance reviews. During the past year, Margaret’s division did not prosper, due to the economy, but it did not suffer, either. And she had not received any negative reports, comments or complaints. As she had each year before, Margaret received word she was to meet with her supervisor to go over her annual review. Nothing new in that; that is what happened each year. Another reason that Margaret didn’t see it coming.

When Margaret met with her supervisor, as was the custom, Margaret was handed a copy of her annual review to read before the two discussed it. As she opened the papers before her, Margaret was startled to see a few comments that seemed negative, and a few “needs improvement” boxes checked. When she saw her overall evaluation to be “Partially Meets Expectations,” her first thought was “They must have given me someone else’s performance review by mistake.” No such luck; it was hers, and it was brutal.

Margaret went silent, and barely spoke a word throughout the entire meeting. As requested Margaret signed her name at the bottom of the last page. Afterwards, she walked straight over to Human Resources, and shared her feelings of upset, anger and betrayal. She was told there was nothing she could do. She was told performance reviews are “not negotiable.” She was told that perhaps she should consider whether her job was really the right fit for her. She was told perhaps she should consider looking “elsewhere.”

She just never saw it coming. Worse still, far worse: she did not know where it was headed.  

LESSON TO LEARN: In the first 25 or so of my 30+ years of working with employees, I shared the commonly held view that Performance Reviews were “no big deal,” that they were not usually cause for concern, and that they surely were not anything an attorney was involved with. The past five years or so has made me feel quite different.

Today, I find that issues of Performance Reviews, and their “cousins,” Performance Improvement Plans, to be among the top reasons people contact me, or review my blogsite. And, yes, I have come to view them as something that an attorney can – and should – help employees with.

That is because they are sometimes “corrupted” by (a) false information, making them potentially fraudulent, (b) improper motivations, such as discrimination or harassment, (c) damaging to professional reputations, and (d) in my humble opinion, increasingly being used to deny employees what they have earned, the protections supposedly afforded them by company policies, or even their jobs. Yes, I have come to view Performance Reviews as sources of significant problems in the workplace.

That said, I am of the view that “for every problem there is a solution.” I strongly suggest that every employee who believes that his or her Performance Review is incorrect, improper or otherwise “corrupted” should respond in an appropriate and effective way. I am also of the firm opinion that, if not addressed promptly and thoughtfully, a negative Performance Review can become a much greater problem, potentially leading to a lower bonus, diminished chances for advancement, loss of ability to transfer within the company, or even job loss.

That is to say, a robust Performance Review Rebuttal both addresses the past, and protects the future. Its goals need to be: (1) to make a correct and true record of your performance; (2) to ensure that negative consequences do not follow, whether a Performance Improvement Plan, a reduced bonus or even job loss; and (3) to show the Reviewer and others that the employee is capable and prepared to defend his or her performance record, and hence his or her career and your family.

Gone is the time that an employee who receives a negative Performance Review can simply say, “Oh, well, I will just try harder next year.” That time is long gone. These days, and henceforth, those facing a problematic Performance Review have no real choice but to submit an effective Performance Review Rebuttal. Here’s how.

WHAT YOU CAN DO: Here are 16 Steps to a Robust Rebuttal to a Performance Review that is  inaccurate, misleading, wrong, unfair, dishonest or otherwise problematic:    Read the rest of this blog post »

Performance Review Approaching? 12 Ways to Enhance Yours

Published on June 20th, 2012 by Alan L Sklover

“It doesn’t matter if a cat is black or white
so long as it catches mice.”

-       Deng Xiaoping

ACTUAL “CASE HISTORIES”: This newsletter issue does not start off with a “case history,” as most do, because there are so many “case histories” on this subject already known to our readers. Each year – and often twice a year – many employers engage in performance reviews of their employees. A significant amount of time, effort and expense goes into the performance review process. 

Ostensibly, the purpose of a performance review is, simply, to review performance. But for what reasons do we do that? A number of reasons come to mind: (a) to give feedback to the employee about those areas of endeavor that can be improved; (b) to determine who should be promoted or demoted; (c) to determine how much of a raise or bonus the employee should receive; (d) to keep everyone focused on performance criteria; and (e) to suggest specific objectives and goals going forward. There are many others, too. 

However, at times the higher purposes of any human endeavor can become corrupted when being put into practice. It’s just a fact of life that those whose job it is to serve us sometimes serve, instead, their own interests. That is why so many of us knowingly laugh at “I’m from the government and I’m here to help you.” After all, humans will be human. Anyone who claims that bosses and HR representatives are better – or worse – than all other humans is simply spouting foolishness. They are humans, period, capable of both noble and ignoble acts.    

In practice, sometimes performance reviews can get corrupted, and end up serving improper purposes, such as: (a) personal animosity; (b) retaliation against those who have reported wrongdoing; (c) denial to people of the bonuses they have in fact earned; or (d) to lay a false foundation upon which to fire people. There are others, too. Sadly, in our experience and in the experience of our clients, the frequency of “corrupted” performance reviews seems to be on the rise.    

Whether your performance review is based solely on your performance, or corrupted by improper purposes, there are things you can do to affect your performance review by ensuring that you are reviewed in the most positive light. We call them “Performance Review Enhancers.”  

LESSON TO LEARN: Whether your upcoming performance review will be properly conducted or improperly conducted, you can influence the light in which you are reviewed, thereby increasing the odds that you will be viewed in the most positive light, so that it serves your interests to the maximum degree possible.  

“But,” you might ask, “since my employer permits me to submit a self-assessment, isn’t that enough?” The answer is “No.” Self-assessments, when used as a part of the performance improvement process, are limited by design as to (a) the subjects you can address, (b) the ways in which you can address them, (c) what additional information you can offer, and (d) who will see your self-assessment. We always counsel clients to go above and beyond those limits.   

The basic idea is to ensure that the most positive information regarding your performance is known, and makes its way into your performance review, and that false, incorrect, and harmful information does not make it into your performance  review in the first place.

For this reason, about six weeks before your next performance review, we highly recommend you take the time to prepare and transmit to your supervisor, manager or department head what we call a “Performance Review Enhancement Memo,” which is simply “all the good news you can muster.”   

Remember that no one will promote or protect your interests if you don’t do so yourself. And remember, too, that the best defense is often a good offense. Preparation is the key. And please never forget this fact: more jobs are lost due to performance reviews than due to any other reason.  

WHAT YOU CAN DO: Here are 12 practical steps you can take to ensure the most successful performance review possible. Each is a step to take in preparation of your own “Performance Review Enhancement Memo.” While not all of our “Performance Review Enhancers” may be applicable to your circumstances, it is quite probable that at least some will be. Each step is a step toward job security and potential advancement, and is so in your interests.      

Read the rest of this blog post »

“How can I overcome a poor in-company reputation?”

Published on February 3rd, 2012 by Alan L Sklover

Question: My reputation as a poor worker has been circling me for the past two years. It is only recently that I learned my supervisor has been adding details to my performance reviews, and sharing them with others. I have reported this, and it is under investigation.

This would explain why my reputation is so terrible. I’ve been passed over for three jobs that I applied for within the company as well as several other projects I’ve volunteered for. I am a “runner,” not a “walker,” always at the top of my game, eager to please and work hard to make accomplishments. How do I correct this situation?

(City and State Not Specified)

Answer: Dear Norma: Reputation repair is a particularly vexing problem. It takes a lifetime to build a good reputation, and only a minute – or a mean person – to ruin one. Here are my thoughts.    

1. Ultimately, it is good work and good relations that build a solid – and almost unshakeable – reputation. There have been so many times in my life that I have heard things said about people I know – and people I know to be great people – that I simply WILL NOT believe unless I see proof of what is being said. We all know that people sometimes start malicious rumors, have jealousy in their hearts, and have self-interest in mind when they say bad things about another person, and so, hopefully, bear in mind “innocent until proven guilty.” For this reason, the ultimate way to dispel a bad reputation is to remain unflappable, and earn and then re-earn your good reputation each day by good work and good relations. There is nothing more effective or more long-lasting than that in “un-building” a poor reputation.

2. Make a proactive written request for an independent, objective new performance review for each of the years in question. Your letter indicates that you have filed a “report” but does not say if (a) it was written, or, more importantly, (b) if it made requests in order to “solve the problem.” Don’t make the big mistake of waiting for Human Resources to come up with solutions for you; you must aggressively and persistently stand up for yourself. Your first written, proactive request – to solve the problem caused by your supervisor’s actions – should be for a new, independent and objective performance review for each of the years in question. It should be written, sent by email, respectful, and to the point: a problem exists that requires a prompt solution.

3. At the same time, make a proactive written request for an “Action Plan” to remedy the wrongful situation. It appears quite likely that your supervisor may have violated two important company policies: (i) retroactive alteration of Performance Reviews, and (ii) breach of confidentiality regarding them. Because “you never get unless you ask,” I would suggest you make a concrete, detailed and practical “Action Plan” for your (a) transfer from your present supervisor, (b) promotion into a different role, and (c) ideal career path for your future, and submit it to your supervisor’s supervisor and Human Resources representative. A transfer, promotion and new position in which to rebuild your tarnished reputation is probably the most valuable goal you can achieve.     

4. Never forget: persistence pays off like nothing else does.  Merely making a report or complaint rarely gets correction of a serious wrong. You need to follow up, sometimes repeatedly. Sometimes it takes going “higher up,” as well, to make it certain that you are not going to “fade away” without correction of what has happened. In each instance, you might remind people that you are only doing what is right, what is in keeping with company policies, and intended to correct a problem, not cause one. You might also consider making mention that it is your hope and expectation that you will not be retaliated against in any way for these efforts.

Norma, anyone faced with a problem reputation at work has an uphill climb in front of them. Don’t despair: a determined person can overcome any obstacle, and this is one many people do, in fact, overcome. Make a plan, proceed with that plan, and stick to that plan, with persistence and then more persistence, and you have every chance for succeeding. 

Thanks for writing in. My bet is on you!!  

Al Sklover

PS: Our Model Letters help people stand up for themselves at work. If you or a friend is soon to face a Severance, Resignation, Bully Boss, Performance Improvement Plan, or other workplace problem, consider a Model Letter as a “Helping Hand Gift.” Just [click here] to view our list.

Help Yourself With
These Unique PERFORMANCE REVIEW Materials

Perf Rw 1: Before Performance Review: Memo to Make It Most Positive Possible
Perf Rw 2: After Performance Review: Model Rebuttal to Performance Review
Perf Rw 3: After Performance Review: Request for Perf. Rebuttal Forms & Procedures
Perf Rw 4: 141-Pt. Master Guide and Checklist for Performance Reviews
Perf Rw 5: After Perf. Review: Model Memo Thanking Manager for Helpful Review

[ Click Here ] and Go to Section "H"

 Repairing the World –
One Empowered and Productive Employee at a Time ™

© 2012 Alan L. Sklover, All Rights Reserved.                                                                             

Alan L. Sklover

Alan L. Sklover

Employment Attorney
and Career Strategist
for over 35 years

Job Security and Career Success now depend on knowing how to navigate and negotiate to gain the most for your skills, time and efforts. Learn the trade secrets and 'uncommon common sense' of Attorney Alan L. Sklover, the leading authority on "Negotiating for Yourself at Work™".

Receive All Our Posts - It's Free!

Monthly Newsletter, Discounts, Events